The Anti-Federalists by Jackson Main, 1961, Edited Excerpts
If we try to form an estimate of the entire white population, the two sides appear to have been nearly equal in numbers. Of course in 1787-88 this was of no importance: what counted then was the ratification by nine states. Since the Federalists were a minority in at least six and probably seven states, they ought surely to have been defeated. Yet they came from behind to win.
Thus wealth and position supported the Constitution. On the other hand, lower ranking army officers and men of lesser economic and social distinction tended to be Antifederal; doctors were to be found on both sides. Combining all of this personal information, a division can be made as follows: men of high social, military, or economic position voted 107 to 34 for ratification, while those of lower status voted 126 to 61 against it.
The Antifederalists asserted that the Constitution created a consolidated government, and if this were so, the members of the Philadelphia Convention had violated their instructions. The convention had acted illegally.
We may conclude that if the Antifederalists had dominated the Philadelphia Convention, the government of the nation would have continued to be a confederation of sovereign states, and that the democratic principle of local self-government would have been emphasized.
The pro-Constitution attitude of the newspapers was undoubtedly important. The number of papers which opposed ratification or even of those which presented both sides impartially was very few. This was natural, for the city people were overwhelmingly Federal, and the printers were influenced by local opinion as well as by their own convictions; moreover, it was profitable to agree with the purchasers and the advertisers.
The Federalist domination of news coverage permitted them not only to obtain more space for their own publications but to conceal or distort the facts. The objections of the Antifederalists were sometimes twisted so as to make them appear foolish; at other times it was denied that there was any opposition at all to the Constitution.
